Diners praise the friendly service, Mexican dishes such as burritos, flautas and the sharing boats, and desserts made at the table. Others are unhappy with the more international menu, mentioning pizza and meat dishes that missed the mark.
Isla Bonita is at Calle Puerto Rico 3, in Puerto Rico, and holds a 3.9 out of 5 rating from 175 Google reviews. Opinions are quite split, so it helps to know what to order.
The Mexican side of the menu gets the best feedback. People who recommend it mention tasty food, very good burritos and flautas, and boats to share. The staff are often described as friendly, and one review loves that the waiter prepares desserts live beside your table.
Another calls it a quiet spot for an unhurried meal with good value, and one reviewer singles out the peach shot.
The complaints are about the wider menu. Several reviews criticise a filet mignon served with frozen vegetables, a carbonara pizza made with tomato, a mixed salad that was only greens, and steak or chicken buried under sauce. One reviewer called it low quality food. The common thread is dishes not matching what you would expect from the name.




