Reviews are sharply split. Happy diners praise the friendly staff, big portions and dishes like the fajitas, hanging kebab and lamb shoulder. Others complain about disappointing pizzas, dishes that don't match the menu, long waits and uneven service. It scores 3.7 from 91 reviews.
El Toro Negro is on Calle Timanfaya in Puerto Rico and opens every day from 8:30am to 11pm. It has a 3.7 rating from 91 Google reviews, and the comments really do swing from one extreme to the other.
Visitors who loved it, mostly writing in English, describe a lively but cosy atmosphere and welcoming, attentive staff. They mention generous portions: a very large pizza, big pork chops, mixed fajitas (one is enough for two), the hanging mixed-meat kebab, large prawns and lamb shoulder.
Some came back two or three times in the same week. One family notes that the football is shown here and that the kids enjoyed the pasta. One diner found the sangria too sweet, put off by the banana in it.
The negative reviews are mostly about the kitchen. People mention pizzas that tasted poor, a caprese salad that didn't have the advertised ingredients, the same sauce on two different fish dishes and a hair in a pasta dish.
Others describe long waits between ordering drinks and food, and service that wasn't friendly at some tables, though other reviews single out the staff for praise. In one case the pizzas were disliked and only one was charged.
If you go, the grilled meats, fajitas and lamb seem to be the safest bets. Order without rushing, say so early if a dish isn't what you expected, and allow extra time if it is busy.




