Diners praise the friendly service, generous portions, mussels, cordon bleu and sauces, plus the live music at night. Complaints focus on the kitchen: meat that can arrive overcooked, a dry skewer and marinara mussels that disappointed. Rated 3.3 from 175 reviews.
El Pirata is on the Paseo Marítimo in Puerto Rico, facing the beach, and reviewers agree the setting and atmosphere are a big plus. Several mention live music in the evening and a lively feel, though one visitor who came out of season found it quiet.
Service is what comes up most. People describe attentive staff, a warm welcome year after year, a table of 20 looked after very well, and waiters who swapped an overcooked fillet steak without being asked. Some also call it good value.
The food divides opinion. Fans single out the big portions, the mussels, the cordon bleu, padrón peppers and sauces such as the pepper sauce, aioli and mojo. Others found the cooking weak: marinara mussels served with rice and lots of tomato sauce, a very dry skewer and meat that was not the best. The pizza does not seem to be the strong point.
The 3.3 rating from 175 reviews reflects that inconsistency. If you go, stick to the grill and the sauces, tell them how you like your meat cooked, and stay on for dinner if you fancy live music.




