Diners praise the fresh fish of the day, the papas arrugadas, generous portions and friendly staff, with good value for money. Complaints include fish cooked a bit too long, a plain seafood grill, desserts running out and waiting without a booking.
The Cofradía de Pescadores in Arguineguín has an average of 4.2 from more than 4,800 Google reviews. Customers describe it as no-frills: a cosy place to eat local fish, with plenty of locals at the tables.
The most repeated dishes are grilled fish of the day, fried fish and papas arrugadas, the Canarian wrinkled potatoes. Garlic prawns, octopus in vinaigrette, gofio escaldado and vieja also get a mention. Several reviews mention generous portions, fair prices and staff who are friendly and advise you not to over-order.
Not everyone was won over. One table found a 900 gram sama overcooked and dry, another expected a more varied seafood grill, and one diner missed desserts, as only ice cream is left later on. Another review complains about the awning being raised, leaving them in the sun on a 37 degree day.
It opens from 12:30pm to 11pm, Tuesday and Thursday to Sunday, and is closed on Mondays and Wednesdays. According to reviews, there are no bookings and tables go in order of arrival. Tip: arrive before 2pm, when one party waited only a few minutes, and order the fish of the day with papas arrugadas. Phone: 928 15 09 63.




