Customers praise the friendly, attentive service, the paella and the pizzas, and say prices are fair for a beachfront spot. Some also mention cheaper beer than at other places along the promenade. Reviews describe a family feel and food that arrives without a long wait.
Casa Italia has a 4.4 rating from 159 Google reviews. If you are looking for Italian food in Puerto Rico, one reviewer ranks its pizzas among the best on the island, though the dish mentioned most often is the paella.
Service is what people praise most. Several reviews describe staff as friendly, attentive and good at making recommendations, and one says visitors and locals are treated the same. It is described as a family-run place where dishes do not take long to arrive.
On price, guests think it is good value for somewhere right by the beach, with talk of good quality for the money and cheaper beer than other bars along the front. One reviewer places it on Amadores beach, so check the address, Calle San Borondón, when you go.
It opens every day from 9am to 11pm, so it works for breakfast, lunch or dinner. Practical tip: go for the paella or a pizza, as these are what customers mention most, and ask the staff for advice, since several reviews say they recommend well.




